Judge’s Review: 92 Rating – Cottage by Tall Oaks Farm and Brewery
Tall Oaks Farm + Brewery
Dark Mild | Limited Release | USA

By Dan Martich
Judges Rating: 92.00
Aroma: 20.00
Appearance: 6.00
Flavor: 39.00
Mouthfeel: 8.00
Overall Impression: 19.00
Cottage by Tall Oaks Farm+ Brewery is being evaluated as a Dark Mild (Category 13A) from the 2021 BJCP Style guidelines.
The beer pours with beautiful clarity, showcasing a rich mahogany brown color. It is topped with a firm, foamy, tan-colored head that exhibits excellent persistence.
Moderate aromas of milk chocolate shavings and dry malt grains dominate the nose, accompanied by notes of raw tree nuts and a subtle hint of green tea. Very low earthy hops are detected.
Roasted coffee notes lead the flavor profile, followed by chocolate and a small amount of grainy toast. The balance is decisively malt-forward. A neutral hop flavor provides moderate bitterness, present just enough to balance the malt character. The finish is short, featuring a pleasant lingering taste of milk chocolate and grain.
Medium-bodied with a moderate level of carbonation, contributing to a smooth and pleasant mouthfeel.
An exceptional example of its style. This is a highly drinkable beer that achieves a great balance of flavor. Its low ABV makes it highly enjoyable as a session beer, proving that a beer can be low in alcohol but high in flavor.
Moderate aromas of milk chocolate shavings and dry malt grains dominate the nose, accompanied by notes of raw tree nuts and a subtle hint of green tea. Very low earthy hops are detected.
Roasted coffee notes lead the flavor profile, followed by chocolate and a small amount of grainy toast. The balance is decisively malt-forward. A neutral hop flavor provides moderate bitterness, present just enough to balance the malt character. The finish is short, featuring a pleasant lingering taste of milk chocolate and grain.
Medium-bodied with a moderate level of carbonation, contributing to a smooth and pleasant mouthfeel.
An exceptional example of its style. This is a highly drinkable beer that achieves a great balance of flavor. Its low ABV makes it highly enjoyable as a session beer, proving that a beer can be low in alcohol but high in flavor.
Share options
Share a link that only Beer Connoisseur subscribers can access